Medals rules and logic
-
Can you explain to me the interest and the representativeness of medals when you can be level 8 in 3 championships. While players with better records and playing battles regularly find themselves much lower
wrote on 28 Dec 2020, 23:09 last edited by
-
wrote on 28 Dec 2020, 23:40 last edited by
-
wrote on 28 Dec 2020, 23:43 last edited by
division 7, 269,000 medals. 11 championships and 53% wins. the calculation for the medals is a total unknown ...
-
wrote on 29 Dec 2020, 15:16 last edited by
The ranking of manager points is much more interesting on all points, than a single place to rank, cooler to evolve, much fairer. The medals, I didn't understand the point of that. several competitions stopped, it's very sad
-
wrote on 29 Dec 2020, 18:07 last edited by otman347891
-
wrote on 29 Dec 2020, 18:18 last edited by
-
wrote on 29 Dec 2020, 19:16 last edited by H Mainguy
The issue is also that there is no reason to play good managers now. I lead a good crew, with players high in the rankings, and some don't want to play in the crew league or in crew competitions anymore because by playing stronger players, their medal number will go down. (Even if they win their league with say 10 wins, 5 draws and 3 losses, that would be about 10x200+5x0-3x1200=-1600 before the end of season bonus - now imagine if they finish with 6/6/6 for example (even with the end of season bonus, you would lose medals). But they would be much better off playing weaker players, and winning everything).
So what is the incentive for playing against strong players? Now, no one will want to play leagues with only top players if they care about their medals. There definitely needs to be a change in the system, and perhaps having one score per slot like for manager points is more suitable. Or simply changing the medal system - there are options to do so, and I can help with that, but the current model needs to be changed.
-
I agree with the medals system, because you have to be fully dedicated to the game and active in every slot. The medals ranking it's the best way of knowing who are the "in-form" playeers. Even though I am already on the 9th division I want to enter leagues that are competitive, so that I can be a better manager. Only playing against CPU and noob players it doesn't motivate me anymore. I din't care If I lose medals. What is the Point of topping the medals ranking if you don't play against the best managers? The players who don't want to participate in competitive leagues simply din't deserve my respect. If everybody play by the rules the medals ranking is pretty cool!
-
wrote on 1 Jan 2021, 19:43 last edited by
The classification of medals on separate locations allows you to play medals and other competitions organized by moderators such as Crew Cup or competitions in our countries.
-
wrote on 1 Jan 2021, 21:04 last edited by
I also want to clarify that if options are deactivated in your championships, you do not get bonus medals at the end of the championship. It's a scam!
-
I agree with the medals system, because you have to be fully dedicated to the game and active in every slot. The medals ranking it's the best way of knowing who are the "in-form" playeers. Even though I am already on the 9th division I want to enter leagues that are competitive, so that I can be a better manager. Only playing against CPU and noob players it doesn't motivate me anymore. I din't care If I lose medals. What is the Point of topping the medals ranking if you don't play against the best managers? The players who don't want to participate in competitive leagues simply din't deserve my respect. If everybody play by the rules the medals ranking is pretty cool!
wrote on 2 Jan 2021, 19:01 last edited by@ruipsc5
HI,
It's like saying to Nadal or Federer, if you lose in the final of Rolland Garros, Wimbledon and the US Open, you will be behind players who have won tournaments in their village in the ATP ranking ... That's what medals are all about. .. It seems to me not complicated to make a system allowing to continue playing big competitions without this being a disadvantage for the classification having in particular to put forward the best OSM players. -
@ruipsc5
HI,
It's like saying to Nadal or Federer, if you lose in the final of Rolland Garros, Wimbledon and the US Open, you will be behind players who have won tournaments in their village in the ATP ranking ... That's what medals are all about. .. It seems to me not complicated to make a system allowing to continue playing big competitions without this being a disadvantage for the classification having in particular to put forward the best OSM players.@timilic7 Hey! In the end of the day, the player who wins more leagues, cups and leagues will top the medals ranking! Once you spoke in a tennis language... The medals ranking is the ATP Champions Race. The regular ranking is the ATP World Ranking. I think there is space for both of them. Have a Nice 2021!
-
@timilic7 Hey! In the end of the day, the player who wins more leagues, cups and leagues will top the medals ranking! Once you spoke in a tennis language... The medals ranking is the ATP Champions Race. The regular ranking is the ATP World Ranking. I think there is space for both of them. Have a Nice 2021!
wrote on 4 Jan 2021, 10:11 last edited byTo win medals, you have to play a lot of league against mediocre coaches. We can not therefore play strong competitions in crew under penalty of falling in the rankings. In the end, either the best players who fight for their ranking will abandon their crew to not go down the rankings, or the ranking will not really be representative of the strength of the players. Sometimes I feel like Gamebasic's goal is to destroy crews. After the end of the old battles, here is another blow to the world of crews. Without the crews and their competitions, a very interesting part of the game would be gone. I have found in the crews that I have frequented more than players, they are my friends (even if it is only virtual), without a crew I think the game would lose a lot of old players, who have contributed a lot to this game. In summary, the problem is not just the medal ranking, but general and if the goal is to prevent players from meeting as a crew, then gamebasic just has to say it openly I would find it braucoup faster. The general level of OSM will be pulled down favoring the noobs who may be spending more coins than the old ones ... (maybe it is OSM's bet?) Good day to you all. Here is my humble opinion.
-
To win medals, you have to play a lot of league against mediocre coaches. We can not therefore play strong competitions in crew under penalty of falling in the rankings. In the end, either the best players who fight for their ranking will abandon their crew to not go down the rankings, or the ranking will not really be representative of the strength of the players. Sometimes I feel like Gamebasic's goal is to destroy crews. After the end of the old battles, here is another blow to the world of crews. Without the crews and their competitions, a very interesting part of the game would be gone. I have found in the crews that I have frequented more than players, they are my friends (even if it is only virtual), without a crew I think the game would lose a lot of old players, who have contributed a lot to this game. In summary, the problem is not just the medal ranking, but general and if the goal is to prevent players from meeting as a crew, then gamebasic just has to say it openly I would find it braucoup faster. The general level of OSM will be pulled down favoring the noobs who may be spending more coins than the old ones ... (maybe it is OSM's bet?) Good day to you all. Here is my humble opinion.
@pagno7 I am part of a crew and have a slot fully dedicated to it. I play competitive leagues where the teams have all the same goal and squad value and where you can't train your players or do friendlies. I try not to play against weak players. And after all that I am top 220 in the World and top 15 in my country. It is possible to perform well on both rankings!
-
wrote on 4 Jan 2021, 23:15 last edited by
@ruipsc5 A location for your Crew.I have three locations for my Crew, of course sometimes my available ones are not used if my Crew needs so we lose points when the location is free, after each one plays as he wants but for my Crew competitionsare much more interesting than doing a basic three championship, without Crew I stop the game.
-
@timilic7 Hey! In the end of the day, the player who wins more leagues, cups and leagues will top the medals ranking! Once you spoke in a tennis language... The medals ranking is the ATP Champions Race. The regular ranking is the ATP World Ranking. I think there is space for both of them. Have a Nice 2021!
wrote on 4 Jan 2021, 23:35 last edited by@ruipsc5
HI,
So we can't understand each other ... Being in the 15 in my country and the top 100 in the world is not necessarily what I call performing ... But what bothers me in this ranking is that it puts the players at a disadvantage. players playing real championships like you or me .. High level battle, WC among other things ...... since in these Championships we necessarily lose more medals than we win .... And to be world top 10 For 3 years in a ranking, the one in coaching points, with two world championship finals and being 120 th in the other I find that totally inconsistent ...
Happy New Year to you too coach !!!! -
@ruipsc5
HI,
So we can't understand each other ... Being in the 15 in my country and the top 100 in the world is not necessarily what I call performing ... But what bothers me in this ranking is that it puts the players at a disadvantage. players playing real championships like you or me .. High level battle, WC among other things ...... since in these Championships we necessarily lose more medals than we win .... And to be world top 10 For 3 years in a ranking, the one in coaching points, with two world championship finals and being 120 th in the other I find that totally inconsistent ...
Happy New Year to you too coach !!!!@timilic7 True! I understand what you are trying to say.
All we have to do is win 20 out of 22 in those competitive championships! 
Good luck, bro! -
@ruipsc5 A location for your Crew.I have three locations for my Crew, of course sometimes my available ones are not used if my Crew needs so we lose points when the location is free, after each one plays as he wants but for my Crew competitionsare much more interesting than doing a basic three championship, without Crew I stop the game.
@nicolas-mangeard In my crew we have 4 static sub-groups composed by 6 players each. One of the elements rests for 1 battle. And we always have 4 battles on going! I really like the crew world!
-
wrote on 5 Jan 2021, 08:12 last edited by
Look, between the first 2 in the medal classification if there are no inconsistencies.
The world's first
The 2nd in the world
And all the players who were top 10 point managers, and who fought to be level. No longer top 10 medal. So for some of the years of play in the trash and it's a shame that all the time passed was forgotten.
-
wrote on 5 Jan 2021, 08:34 last edited by
Hello everyone, I would like to respond to this debate, hoping that an employee will read us one day.
I sincerely think that the implementation of a new points / medals system is a good thing, it allows the previous points system to evolve and I find that rather good. Unfortunately, the current system is not fair. I agree with everything that has already been said here. and the major problem is the recording of points on all 4 accounts, which therefore obliges all managers to play on their 4 accounts. or some do not have the time or wish to organize fun or on the contrary very competitive championships (crew championship, national competition, WC etc.)
It would be very welcome to obtain the precise calculation of the obtaining of medals for a victory, a draw or a defeat according to the various criteria for more transparency. I think there are things that need to be changed to avoid the ranking inconsistencies mentioned above.